126 RAYS OF POSITIVE ELECTRICITY
cathode rays hit the salt or not. As both these conditions have
a great influence on the rate of production of helium we may
regard this source as eliminated. In addition to the preced-
ing considerations some of the cathodes have been in almost
continuous use for months without any perceptible diminution
In the rate of supply of helium.

There Is another possibility which It Is much more difficult
to eliminate by means of physical experiments, though the
chemical properties of the inert gases may be thought to make
It very improbable; this Is that helium can combine with a
large number of elements and that these helium compounds
exist as Impurities In the salts of these elements and that these
compounds of helium, present as impurities In soluble salts,
are also soluble. The fact that helium Is given off by nearly
every substance shows that this solid compound or compounds
must be extremely widely spread if it is to explain the helium
production. They must also possess very special chemical
properties in order to explain a large number of cases of which
the following Is an example: if we take AgNO3, a salt which
will give some helium on bombardment, dissolve it in water,
add HC1, we get a precipate of AgCl, now this silver chloride
on bombardment will also give helium.

Thus If compounds of helium are present as Impurities
they must be precipitated by the same chemical reactions as
precipitate the salts of the element with which they are
mixed. It must I think be acknowledged that to explain the
production of helium by the dissociation of helium compounds
present as impurities obliges us to assign to helium chemical
properties of a much more energetic kind than those usually
assigned to It. On the other hand there are some effects
connected with the appearance of helium which suggest that
the source of this gas is not the whole mass of the salt but
only a small fraction of it, and which would in fact be more